Servicing Areas Throughout New Jersey

Water Heater Replacement in Shrewsbury, NJ

Hot Water Back Today, Not Next Week

Professional water heater replacement service that gets your Shrewsbury home running normally again without the runaround.

A man in blue overalls and a light blue shirt is installing or inspecting a wall-mounted water heater in a bathroom. The room is bright and contains shelves with towels and toiletries.

Reviews

100% Customer Satisfaction

A woman in an orange shirt is on the phone while adjusting a control panel on a white appliance, possibly a boiler or heater. The setting is indoors, with a bright, modern background.

New Water Heater Installation Shrewsbury

What You Get When It's Done Right

Your morning shower runs hot again. No more rationing hot water between family members or timing dishwasher loads around everyone else’s schedule.

You get a water heater that’s properly sized for your home’s needs. Not the cheapest unit that’ll fail in three years, but one that matches your household’s hot water demand and runs efficiently for the long haul.

The installation is clean and professional. We protect your floors, clean up our mess, and explain how your new system works before we leave. You’re not left wondering if something’s wrong every time you hear a new sound.

Shrewsbury Water Heater Specialists

Local Plumbers Who Actually Show Up

We’ve been handling water heater replacements throughout Shrewsbury and Monmouth County for years. We’re the local team homeowners call when they need the job done right the first time.

Our technicians are licensed, insured, and know the common issues with water heaters in older Shrewsbury homes. We’ve replaced units in everything from historic properties near Sickles Park to newer developments, so we understand what works in this area.

When you call us, you’re working with plumbers who live and work in this community. We’re not a national chain that rotates different crews through your neighborhood every month.

A smiling person in a blue uniform and cap is holding a clipboard and pen. They stand in front of various plumbing and heating equipment in a utility room.

Water Heater Replacement Process Shrewsbury

Simple Process, Professional Results

First, we assess your current water heater and your home’s hot water needs. We measure your space, check your gas or electrical connections, and discuss whether you want to stick with your current type or upgrade to something more efficient like a tankless unit.

Next, we give you upfront pricing for the replacement. No surprises, no “we’ll see when we get in there” pricing games. You know what you’re paying before we start any work.

Then we handle the installation professionally. We remove your old unit safely, install the new water heater according to local codes, test everything thoroughly, and clean up. You get hot water back the same day, plus we explain how to maintain your new system for maximum lifespan.

A hand holding a wrench is adjusting parts on top of a water heater. Two colored valves, one blue and one red, are visible on the surface, indicating hot and cold water connections.

Ready to get started?

Explore More Services

About AME Plumbing Heating and Cooling

Get a Free Consultation

Gas Electric Tankless Water Heaters

Options That Actually Fit Your Situation

We install gas, electric, and tankless water heaters depending on what makes sense for your Shrewsbury home. If you’ve got good gas service and want fast recovery, gas units work well. Electric water heaters are reliable and work excellent when gas isn’t available or practical.

Tankless water heaters are popular with homeowners who want to save space and reduce energy costs. They heat water on demand instead of keeping a tank hot 24/7. They work especially well in smaller homes or when you’re renovating and want to free up basement or utility room space.

We help you choose based on your family’s hot water usage, available utilities, and budget. No pushing the most expensive option just because we can. We install what works for your specific situation and explain why it’s the right choice for your home.

A man in a hard hat and safety glasses is adjusting a control on a wall-mounted cylindrical device, possibly a water heater. He is wearing a checkered shirt and overalls, and the room has white walls with a visible door.
Most water heater replacements take 2-4 hours depending on your home’s setup and the type of unit you’re installing. Straight replacements where we’re swapping similar units go faster. If you’re switching from tank to tankless or need electrical or gas line modifications, it takes longer. We’ll give you a realistic timeframe upfront so you can plan your day accordingly. Emergency replacements often happen the same day you call.
If your water heater is over 8-10 years old and having problems, replacement usually makes more sense than repair. Older leaking units, not heating properly, or making unusual noises are typically near the end of their useful life. Repairs on old units often buy you a few months before the next problem hits. We’ll assess your specific situation honestly and tell you if a repair makes sense or if you’re better off replacing it now.
Water heater sizing depends on your household size and hot water usage patterns. A family of four typically needs a 40–50- gallon tank or a properly sized tankless unit. But it also depends on how many people shower back-to-back, whether you run dishwashers and washing machines simultaneously, and your specific usage habits. We calculate the right size based on your actual needs, not just a generic chart. Getting the sizing right means you have enough hot water without paying to heat more than you need.
Yes, we install tankless water heaters in older homes, but we evaluate each situation carefully. Older homes sometimes need electrical upgrades for electric tankless units or gas line modifications for gas tankless systems. We assess your current utilities, available space, and hot water demand before recommending tankless. When they work, tankless units save space and energy. When your home’s infrastructure isn’t ready, we’ll explain what modifications would be needed and help you decide if it’s worth the investment.
Water heater replacement costs vary based on the type of unit, installation complexity, and any necessary modifications to your plumbing or electrical systems. Basic tank replacements typically cost less than tankless installations or situations requiring significant plumbing changes. We provide upfront pricing after assessing your specific situation, so you know exactly what you’re paying before we start work. No surprise charges or “additional fees discovered during installation.”
Yes, we provide emergency water heater replacement for Shrewsbury homeowners dealing with complete failures or dangerous situations like gas leaks or significant water damage. We understand that losing hot water isn’t just inconvenient—it disrupts your entire household routine. Our emergency service focuses on getting you back up and running quickly with a proper installation, not a quick fix that’ll cause problems later. We stock common water heater sizes to handle most emergency replacements the same day.